13 Social Media Marketing Mistakes that you need to avoid as a handmade business owner

We are all sometimes guilty of making social media marketing mistakes, but what exactly are they? The list could be pretty long, but lets just focus on the few main ones.

I’ve made some of these mistakes in my own handmade business, so I know that even with the best intentions, it’s easy to push social media marketing to one side.

By sharing my experience, I hope to help you avoid the same pitfalls and make your social media marketing more effective and also enjoyable at the same time.

1. starting Social media account and not completing it

A half-finished profile page with incomplete details and a mismatched design will only give the wrong impression to any potential customer.

If it’s March now and your latest update was wishing everyone a Merry Christmas, what signals do you think this sends? Transfer your attention to detail from your crafting to your online promotion and get creative with cover photographs and profile images.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

2. Not having a coherent branding

Use the same colours, matching logo and type of photos that you have on your website to ensure that your branding is seamless. A polished, professional social media page will create the impression that you’re serious about your business and dedicated to every aspect of it.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

3. Don’t spread yourself too thin

Many people make the mistake of taking on too much and doing worse because of it.  You don’t have to be anywhere and everywhere when it comes to social media – be choosey and pick which channels will work best for you and your business.

If you’re unsure whether or not you’ll be able to fully engage with online users on a particular medium, don’t sign up for it. Limiting yourself to two or three social media channels will allow you to concentrate your efforts. After all, it’s better to be brilliant at one thing than average at lots.

For creative business I would always recommend visual social media (Instagram, Pinterest), Facebook because despite its possible demise in recent times, it’s still a place where a lot of people are, YouTube if you are into tutorials or want to show people videos from behind the scenes of your business.

X (former Twitter) is increasingly becoming visual too, so it’s worth considering, especially if you want to connect with people in your creative niche.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

4. It’s not all about you

How many times have you become disenchanted with a Facebook page or Twitter account due to overload? This is another of those crucial social media marketing mistakes, we often forget that it’s not all about us!

Constantly bombarding your followers with your new creations and solely focusing on your own goings-on will bore your audience. Present your followers with a range of content that is of value to them, even if it does not immediately benefit your sales. Give a little and get a lot in the long-term. It’s proven that any potential customer needs to somehow connect with you about 7 times, before they purchase.

If they see a story about your background or how you started your creative business, they will be interested. After that they might see a little tutorial you’ve posted on YouTube and from that they will probably go to your website to read your blog.

If then they see a post about a last minute space available on your sewing workshop, they will book without hesitation. There is a whole psychology behind this and whether you are doing this naturally (e.g.promoting yourself indirectly) or more methodically – it does work!

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

5. Not being consistent

Another example of social media marketing mistakes, is not being consistent enough. When someone signs up to follow your page, signs up to your newsletter or follows you on social media, they often anticipate your digital presence to be a consistent fixture in their social media bubble.

Posting sporadically and failing to uphold this expectation will only irritate them, leaving them feeling neglected and disillusioned with your brand.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

6. Not engaging with your followers & replying to comments

Failing to respond to comments, questions, or messages can make potential customers feel ignored and less likely to buy.

Good practices for engaging with your followers on social media include replying to comments and messages in a friendly and timely way, so people feel heard and valued.

You can also ask questions in your posts, like which colours or designs your followers like best, to get them involved and show you care about their opinions.

Sharing customer photos, running fun polls, or hosting small giveaways are other great ways to create a sense of community and keep people excited about your handmade business.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

7. Using poor quality photos

Handmade products rely heavily on visual appeal. Posting low-quality or poorly lit photos can deter potential buyers.

To improve your photos, start by using natural light whenever possible, as it makes your products look bright and true to colour. Try taking pictures near a window during the day, and avoid using harsh flash.

Use a simple, clean background so your product stands out, and make sure the area is tidy. Take photos from different angles to show off all the details, and use your phone’s editing tools to adjust brightness or crop out distractions.

You can also use props to compliment your handmade products and help tell their story. For example, if you make handmade soaps, you could place your soaps on a pretty dish with some fresh flowers or a rolled towel nearby to create a spa-like feel.

If you knit hats, you might show the hat next to a cozy mug of hot chocolate or a favourite book. Props should be simple and not distract from your product, but instead make your photos more interesting and inviting.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

8. Not planning ahead

Decide how often your want to post across your social media platforms and stick to it. If you are not sure ‘how often’ there are whole loads of statistics available on this, but I would recommend to start with you. Ask yourself what is realistic, what can you physically do in a week, month or year?

There is no point setting yourself up to fail, wanting to write a blog post every single day, but once or twice a month is more realistic.

Take an empty diary for a week or a month and map out your strategy. Once you have it, try to stick to it for at least a month, review it and monitor what works or what doesn’t.

HANDMADE BUSINESS TIPS

9. Not sharing the process or stories behind your handmade products

Not sharing behind-the-scenes content or the process of making the items misses an opportunity to highlight the uniqueness and value of handmade goods.

For example, if you knit handmade scarves, you could share a series of photos or a short video showing each step—from choosing the yarn colours to knitting the first few rows, and finally finishing the scarf.

You could also tell a story about why you picked a certain colour or pattern, like making a blue scarf inspired by your favourite winter memory. This lets your followers see the care and creativity that goes into each product, making your scarves feel more special and personal.

10. Not reviewing your social media strategy regularly

Each social media usually has some sort of analytics, where you can find out your reach and get more of an understanding how your audience reacts to your updates. Check your social media analytics at least once a month and review your strategy accordingly.

It’s amazing what you can find! The post that you thought was the most brilliant ever, might not have got as many ‘likes’, impressions or shares as the one that you didn’t even think would be much good.

11. Not defining a target audience

Trying to appeal to everyone rather than defining and targeting a specific niche can dilute your brand and messaging.

To define your target audience on social media for a handmade business, start by thinking about who would love and use your products the most. Look at things like their age, interests, and where they spend time online. Once you know who you want to reach, you can create posts and content that speak directly to them and make them excited about your handmade items.

For example, if you make colourful friendship bracelets, your target audience might be teenage girls who enjoy fashion and crafts. You could post fun photos and videos on Instagram and TikTok, using bright colours and popular music that appeals to that age group. This way, your content is more likely to catch their attention and get them interested in your bracelets.

12. Over promoting without adding any value

Constantly pushing products without offering helpful content, inspiration, or tips can turn followers away.

When promoting your handmade business on social media, try not to only post about your products or ask people to buy from you all the time. Instead, share helpful tips, behind-the-scenes looks at how you make your items, or fun stories about your creative process. This way, your followers get to know you and your business better, and they’ll be more interested in what you have to offer.

For example, if you make handmade candles, don’t just post pictures saying “Buy my candles!” every day. Instead, you could share a video showing how you pour the wax, or write a post with tips on how to make your candles last longer. This gives your followers something interesting or useful, and makes them more likely to remember and trust your business.

13. Not checking your website analytics

And since I’m getting you to check each social media analytics, I would also like to encourage you to check out your website google analytics. So far we’ve been talking about social media mistakes, but the biggest mistake (possibly) is to spend time on something that doesn’t actually bring any traffic to your website.

And traffic means increased visibility, which means more shares, likes, comments and of course more sales. So, next time when you are looking at your google analytics, check out the website traffic sources and then social media referrals. You can clearly see which social media brings you the most traffic and which one is worth focusing on.

I think we have only scratched the surface of social media marketing mistakes, so which ones do you think we should avoid? What did you find that works for you or doesn’t? I love to know, so leave me a comment.

Originally written on 21 Feb 2015 and last updated on 7 June 2025